Partner Insight: 'To be truly sustainable, funds need an active dimension'

clock • 1 min read

When it comes to fixed income, passive index strategies face a number of limitations. Chief among these is the data challenge. Due to the nature of the fixed income universe, where a large number of issuers are not publicly listed companies, data coverage is average at best, with up to 40% of the investment universe typically not covered. Naturally, this creates a problem for building an ESG fixed income index.

But even where data is available, there is no guarantee that a company with a high ESG score is truly making the world a better place. Graeme Anderson, a founding partner at TwentyFour Asset Management, says "rule-based systems can be gamed" by large corporations that have money to throw at ESG reporting, resulting in ESG data being skewed in their favour. He gives Coca-Cola as an example, a company most of us would not consider an ESG investment. The company contributes to plastic pollution and child obesity by selling sugary drinks to children.

However, Anderson points out that in most databases, the company scores well as it knows how to profile itself. "So if you just take a rating or a profile with a passive fund, you're probably buying Coca-Cola," he says.

More on Partner Insight

Partner Insight: Advisers - want to feel closer to your clients?

Partner Insight: Advisers - want to feel closer to your clients?

Advising on philanthropy can help to build relationships

Gareth Jones
clock 08 February 2024 • 1 min read
Partner Insight: How philanthropy advice could head off a client crisis

Partner Insight: How philanthropy advice could head off a client crisis

Younger clients are more likely to want advice on charitable giving

Gareth Jones
clock 06 February 2024 • 1 min read
Partner Insight: Will lower quality credit keep performing?

Partner Insight: Will lower quality credit keep performing?

Investors will need to be more selective than ever

Gareth Jones
clock 12 January 2024 • 1 min read
Trustpilot