Go to Investment Week homepage
  • Site search
  • Job search
  • Subscribe
  • Newsletter
  • Mobile
  • RSS
  • Home
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Fund Manager Views
  • Interviews
  • Sector Analysis
  • Features
  • Events
  • Audio/Video
  • Jobs
  • Research Centre
  • Share Centre
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Advertise
  • UK
  • Global
  • Fixed Income
  • Managed
  • Specialist
  • Markets
  • Goslings Grouse
  • Contrarian Investor
  • Leader
  • The Alchemist
  • The Big Interview
  • Fund Manager Focus
  • Funds to watch (RADAR)
  • Practical
  • Technical
  • The Big Question
  • Conjecture
Where am I? breadcrumbs arrow image Home breadcrumbs arrow image  Feature breadcrumbs arrow image Investment breadcrumbs arrow image Investment Trusts

FEATURE - INVESTMENT TRUSTS

Feeling the hand of history

23 Nov 2009 | 09:00
Staff

Categories: Investment Trusts

Topics: Ima | F&c | Aic | | Retail distribution review

  • Tweet

The investment trust industry has funded everything from the building of railways across the US to the development of South American economies in the 19th century.

This history is both the sector's strength and weakness and, in the week when Investment Week recognises the excellence within the sector, it is worth examining the relevance of the investment trust structure in today's investment markets.

The weakness is that some individual trust boards continue to operate with the limited corporate governance that existed in 19th-century Britain, and some large generalist trusts have ignored the way markets have developed in the past 10 years.

One thing that can been said in favour of activist investors is they have put some of those boards under pressure to make them realise they operate investment trusts for the benefit for shareholders and not just themselves.

Equally, it is true to say none of the major management companies operate the same sleepy investment policies they did 10 or 20 years ago.

You can question the approach by the likes of Witan or F&C to use third-party managers in a funds of funds manner, but you cannot criticise them for not moving with the markets.

Big generalist trusts with global equity mandates will come back into fashion and, with markets as volatile as they currently are, now is a good time to take another look at them.

One of the industry's strengths has been its continuous promotion to private investors and the AIC should take credit for organising small events to promote trusts to private investors and this is something the IMA would do well to learn from.

The investment company market has proved very capable of embracing innovation in terms of structures and asset classes and this year's Investment Trust of the Year Awards shortlists encompass trusts from sectors as diverse as distressed debt, hedge funds, private equity, as well as single-country equity funds.

The closed-ended vehicle structure sits very well with some of these specialist or niche sectors that require long-term buy and hold strategies to avoid the volatility caused by fund flows in the more fickle open-ended market.

This is a major reason why more intermediaries should be actively analysing and using closed-ended funds on behalf of their clients, but the sector at the moment is only regularly used by a small part of the advisory community.

The vagaries of discounts and net asset values are among the excuses often quoted by doubters of investment trusts, leaving the cynical observer to think that commission is the real main reason. The more transparent charging structure is clearly one of the strengths of ITs and if RDR is implemented in its current guises as well as making advisers consider index funds and ETFs it will also mean they have to actively consider investment trusts.

It is always wrong to talk about a renaissance or the death of investment trusts, the fact of the matter is they never go away and the sector continues to be a source of both innovation and good investment returns.

What needs to change is not the sector, but the attitude of the broader advisory market because there is no credible reason for trusts to be ignored by advisers as widely as they are.

  • Print
  • Share
  • Comment
  • Feeling the hand of history

More investment trustsnews

  • Attack of the arbs: The trusts at risk from activists

  • IT dividend rule 'could hit shareholders in the pocket'

  • Train: How I outperformed FTSE All Share during 2011

  • Fees of the future

Email alerts

  • Get similar articles direct to your inbox

Related information

Recommended reading

  • Why the eurozone has more than 12 months left

  • Rogers wary of US equities despite roaring markets

  • SWAG: the industry's latest acronym

  • Pinakin Patel joins JPMorgan

  • Conjecture: High Yield Bonds

Categories

  • Investment Trusts

Topics

  • IMA

  • F&C

  • AIC

  • retail distribution review

Categories: Investment Trusts

Topics: Ima | F&c | Aic | | Retail distribution review

  • Comment
  • Email to a friend
  • Print

COMMENTS

There are no comments submitted yet. Do you have an interesting opinion? Then be the first to post a comment.Post a comment

MOST COMMENTED ARTICLES

  • Spurs boss Redknapp cleared of tax evasion charges

  • FATCA: US Treasury updates proposals to ease burden

  • Woodford ditches Tesco as Buffett buys

  • Buffett: Bonds should come with a health warning

  • Investors 'twice as likely' to choose active funds over trackers - Lipper

AUDIO/VIDEO

  • Conjecture: High Yield Bonds

  • Conjecture: Global Emerging Markets

  • VIDEO: Why Japan is set for a recovery in 2012

  • Conjecture: Global Equities

  • Conjecture: Fixed Income

THE BIG QUESTION

fragment image

Every week, we ask the experts for their views on the latest topics in the industry

  • View all

EVENTS

  • fund5live

  • Senate Spring Investment Conference

  • Absolute Returns Focus 2012

  • Most read
  • Popular topics
  • Related articles
  • Why the eurozone has more than 12 months left

  • Rogers wary of US equities despite roaring markets

  • SWAG: the industry's latest acronym

  • Pinakin Patel joins JPMorgan

  • Conjecture: High Yield Bonds

  • Close Brothers
  • IMF
  • Inflation
  • Italy
  • Portugal
  • Schroders
  • Spain
  • US
  • Warren Buffett
  • eu
  • Revealed: The 20 most consistent funds over three tough years

  • LGIM's Ellis: Why RDR spells end for 1.5% AMCs

  • Revealed: OBSR's top special situations' funds

  • FMYA 2011 shortlist announced

  • What's so special?

EDITOR'S CHOICE

1 2 3 4

hale-clive

View from the Bridge: Investment biker

Being a long time motorbiker, I am very conscious of the ever present threat that comes from being unaware of what is in front of you.

Jupiter tops Alpha Manager provider list

Jupiter Unit Trust Managers employs the most FE Alpha Managers with 12 on the newly revealed list for 2012.

lawrence-gosling

Gosling's Grouse: Baying for blood

When a phlebotomist sticks a needle in a vein you pay attention. He or she has you just where they want you.

obama-concerned

FDR, Reagan, Clinton or Obama: When were markets strongest?

Three years into Barack Obama's term as US president, how do equity market returns under this administration compare with those seen under previous leaders?

DIGITAL EDITION

fragment image

Investment Week digital edition

Register now to receive Investment Week in your inbox.

@INVESTMENTWEEK

fragment image

Follow IW on Twitter

Sign up to have all Investment Week's news and analysis tweeted straight to your timeline.
  • Home
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Fund Manager Views
  • Interviews
  • Sector Analysis
  • Features
  • Events
  • Audio/Video
  • Jobs
  • Research Centre
  • Share Centre
logo

© Incisive Media Investments Limited 2012, Published by Incisive Financial Publishing Limited, Haymarket House, 28-29 Haymarket, London SW1Y 4RX, are companies registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 04252091 & 04252093

  • Site search

sponsored by

Site Credentials:

  • Contact us
  • About Incisive Media
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Accessibility
  • Sitemap

Related websites:

  • IFAonline
  • Professional Adviser
  • Mortgage Solutions
  • Retirement Planner
  • ETFM
  • International Investment
  • Professional Pensions
  • Global Pensions

Jobs:

  • Director/Executive jobs
  • Investment Adviser jobs
  • Investment Analyst jobs
  • Portfolio Manager jobs
  • Private Client Stockbroker jobs
  • Wealth Manager jobs

Accreditations:

  • Digital Publisher of the Year 2010
Tweet